PUT-IN-BAY RENTAL HOMES2023-04-21T20:12:50+00:00

The 5 Most Important Things To Know When Booking Put-in-Bay Rental Homes

Downtown Put-in-Bay Rental Homes! Swim Up Bar!

Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes Downtown Put-in-Bay

Since the Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes were built in 2013, they have reshaped home rentals at Put-in-Bay. No more packing sheets, towels, linens, and blankets for your rental home. You’re on vacation. You deserve it!

No more shuttling in and out of town to get to your rental home. Daily makeup service, fitness center, swim-up bar & grill, and so much more await your next visit!

Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes were built with your comfort in mind. Every villa rental home has three full bathrooms, two comfortable decks looking out over a lushly landscaped courtyard with waterfall & splash pad. BBQ Grills for your use along with loads of outdoor group size tables & chairs. Inside you’ll find four bedrooms in our eight-person units and five bedrooms in our twelve-person villas.

A living room and kitchen, along with 55inch TV’s and Direct TV Satellite service complete the modern downtown rental homes. Guests will enjoy being just a block away from the vibrant nightlife, live entertainment, top Put-in-Bay Restaurants, and shopping. Many of the area attractions are just a short walk away, and our on-site golf cart rentals make it easy to get to those that are not.

Make your vacation memories last a lifetime when you stay at the Put-in-Bay Villas Rental Homes in downtown Put-in-Bay. Our homes have redefined the standard for comfort, convenience, and value. Come and find out for yourself why the Put-in-Bay Villas are the obvious choice for a downtown rental.



The Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes

Put-in-Bay’s Only downtown rental homes. Four & Five Bedroom Rental Homes all with three full bathrooms, kitchens, 2 decks, pool & swim up bar. The island best location & newest homes.

  • Four & Five Bedroom Rental Homes

  • 3 Full Sized Bathrooms

  • 2 Decks To Enjoy

  • Well Equipped Workout Room

  • Heated Swimming Pool With Swim-Up Bar

Picture of the Rental Homes kitchen

Click images below for full size view


Put-in-Bay’s Most Sought After Downtown Rental Home!

Less than 30 yards from the mains strip in downtown Put-in-Bay is the All-Star Ohio House. The home is the most popular large party rental home on the island and ideal for large families or social groups. This Victorian Style Home was built in the early,1900s and in 2012, it was purchased by two die-hard Ohio State Fans. The home was gutted to the studs and modernized in a project that took over a year to complete.

The house is located less than 30 yards from the main strip where you will find the Put-in-Bay Restaurants & Bars and all the shopping you can handle! THe kids will love the large park with numerous play areas to enjoy.

The result was an incredible rental property that sleeps up to 22 people with three large bathrooms, a full kitchen, six bedrooms, and two decks, one in the front and one in the rear. The ample rear deck area is ideal for BBQs and corn hole games, and the front deck is perfect for watching the tourists stroll by.

Guest enjoy VIP access to the islands top-ranked pool & swim-up bar at the Put-in-Bay Resort just 30 yards away. The living room with it’s 60″ LCD TV and Direct TV satellite service is an ideal place to gather the group for the big game. The house rents as one whole unit with parking for three vehicles.

To book the All Star Ohio House click here just call the central reservation center at 833-742-7827

Click images below for full size view


Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes Highlights

  • 4 & 5 Bedroom Rental Homes

  • 3 Full Bathrooms In Every Home

  • Each Rental Home Features 2 Decks

  • Heated Swimming Pool

  • Swim Up Bar & Grill

  • Well Equipped Fitness Center

  • “55” Inch LCD Tv’s In Each Home

  • Put-in-Bay’s Only Downtown Home Rentals

  • Continental Breakfast (except Saturday)

  • Free Parking (Cars Not Recommended)

  • Sheets Towels & Linens Provided

  • Daily Make Up Service By Request

  • Lushly Landscaped Courtyard With Seating

  • Waterfall & Splashpad

  • Blue Marlin Grill On Site

Frequently Asked Question (FAQ’s) About Homes For Rent On The Put-in-Bay Island

Can We Have Extra Guests In Put-in-Bay Hotel Rooms Or Home Rentals2020-02-15T16:01:01+00:00

No this is not permitted. The State of Ohio Fire Marshall sets occupancy limits for all hotels and rentals and owners are not permitted to exceed those limits under any circumstances. Always be sure to book enough rooms for your group as their will rarely be anything left to book last minute. All locations are strict bout the enforcement of these rules. If a room at a Put-in-Bay hotel is advertised as a six-person suite, then it is a six-person maximum


Where Should We Stay At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T15:56:33+00:00

Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of lodging options. The preferred option is to stay is in town within walking distance of the attractions, nightlife, and dining. There are several hotels and downtown home rentals that eliminate the need to rely on transportation into and out of town. Taxis can be expensive and time-consuming and often hard to find. The central reservation center can assist you in booking the best lodging for your needs. The Put-in-Bay Visitors & Convention Bureau is another great option for the island’s preferred lodging.

Where Can I Find Information About Put-in-Bay Hotels2020-02-15T15:51:01+00:00

Put-in-Bay Hotels and resorts all maintain their own individual websites. Much of the information you are seeking may be found on our lodging page or the hotels’ website. The Put-in-Bay Visitors and Convention Bureau also is a great source for hotels and lodging information about Put-in-bay. Each hotel has an individual page here for you to review information and pictures. You can also call the reservation center for Put-in-Bay at 888-742-7829

Where can I Find Deals And Discounts Or Packages For Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T14:51:28+00:00

We recommend visiting Put-in-Bay hotels downtown rental home websites. The Put-in-Bay Visitors & Convention Bureau maintains a page with the current hotel, resort, and home rental specials. Visit their website for the most up to date information on discounts and packages for Put-in-Bay.



Where Is The Best Place To Stay At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T14:38:46+00:00

There are many different choices for lodging at Put-in-Bay, and where the best place is will depend a lot on you and your group. Most people want to be in town and close to the restaurants, shopping, and nightlife where everything is walkable. If you are not able to get a place in town, you may find yourself stuck having to rely on a taxi to get back and forth. We suggest starting with the Put-in-Bay Resort, The Edgewater Hote, The Put-in-Bay Villa Home Rentals or the Bay Lodging Resort.



How Do We Get The Cheapest Deal On Hotels And Home Rentals At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T14:28:11+00:00

Book direct! Call the hotel or resort directly or use their online booking to reserve. Online travel agents like Expedia and Booking.com make their profit by charging you a fee (generally 15% more) for using their service. The central reservation center 888-742-7829 will also often know of specials and packages that can make for a more affordable stay. All of our lodging partners may be contacted directly on this site with just a click or a phone call!

Can You Stay Just One Night At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T14:24:03+00:00

During some parts of the season in April Late September and October, Put-in-Bay Resort & Bay Lodging may offer single night stays on weekends. In Peak season on weekends, all rentals require a 2-night minimum stay. Holiday weekends are often a thee night minimum. The central reservation center is generally the best information option and will have the most current lodging info at 888-742-7829

Where Is A Good Place For Bachelor Or Bachelorette Parties At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T14:12:38+00:00

Put-in-Bay is well-known for bachelor and bachelorette parties.  It has been ranked as one of the best places to hold a bachelor and bachelorette party in the Midwest. The most popular locations for these groups are in the downtown area. When in town, nobody needs a taxi to get around. The Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes, Edgewater Hotel Suite and the Put-in-Bay resort all feature rooms and lodging for larger groups. All of the aforementioned are in town, and walking distance to the Put-in-Bay Nightlife, Shopping, and Dining.


How Much Does It Cost To Stay At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T13:59:57+00:00

Put-in-Bay Hotels and rental homes are more expensive on weekends. During the week, Sunday through Thursday rates are significantly lower. Groups lodging together tend to get the best rates per person in the larger downtown rental homes. Some hotels and resorts offer package deals with a golf cart included in the rate. There is a central reservation center that generally knows what the best deals on lodging are. Their number is 888-742-7829


Can I Rent A House At Put-in-Bay2020-02-15T13:48:32+00:00

Yes! There are several modern houses for rent at Put-in-Bay called the Put-in-Bay Villas and the All-Star Ohio House. Like any vacation rental, you want to be close to town where walking to the shops and restaurants is possible. When booking a Put-in-Bay Rental home be sure that you are in town and that sheets, towels, and linens are provided as some primitive rentals do not offer them.


Picture of the Fitness Center at the Put-in-Bay Rental Homes



Picture of the Pool At the Put-in-Bay Rental Homes


Pool & Swim-Up Bar

Go to Top