The History Of Put-in-Bay Restaurants
Since the 1800’s, Put-in-Bay Restaurants have always been trendsetters early on. The Beebe House and the famous Victory Hotel boasted dining rooms seating over 500 people. In early Put-in-Bay History, steamships would bring visitors to Put-in-Bay by the thousands to enjoy the resort island, and Put-in-Bay Restaurants were an essential part of the equation.
Over the years, most of the original Put-in-Bay Restaurants, such as the Colonial, were destroyed by fire or converted to another use. Ironically most of the restaurants at Put-in-Bay today began their life as something else! The current location of Mossbacks Restaurant was once the Put-in-Bay Hardware Store. The Old Forge began it’s life as a blacksmiths shop and then for many years was a gift shop. The Put-in-Bay Brewery once was home to the Put-in-Bay Volunteer Fire Department and is now the only distillery located on an island in Ohio!
Along Delaware Avenue, the main strip, the Frosty Bar, was once a dry goods store. The T&J’s Smokehouse was a hotel and then known as The Crescent Restaurant operated for many years by the Stoiber Family. The Goat was once a winery and then ran as Daily’s Tavern by the family of legendary Pat Daily, a famous Put-in-Bay Entertainer for many years. Be sure to venture into the interior of the island where you will find Joe’s Bar. The self-proclaimed king of dive bars!
The wide diversity of food offered at Put-in-Bay Restaurants has evolved over the years, and present-day offers just about every popular food one would desire. The General rule of thumb for the dress is resort casual. Many of the local restaurants rely on seasonal workers to help staff and care for the large crowds that vacation at Put-in-Bay each season.
Restaurants at Put-in-Bay face unique challenges in their operation in that all products must be brought to the island by ferry boat. This includes all liquor beer & wine (except those produced locally) Aside from the added expense of transportation, careful planning of inventory levels is critical. Restaurants running out of an item is not an option when restocking means a lengthy and expensive trip to the mainland! Be sure to enjoy some freshly caught Lake Erie Yellow Perch or Walleye, a regional favorite served at many restaurants and Put-in-Bay Hotels!
Put-in-Bay Restaurants Literally Have Something For Everyone
A quick bite, romantic weekend dinner, lunch to go options abound for guests. Local Lake Erie Fish, such as the Yellow Perch or the flavorful Walleye Platter, is always a popular selection. South Bass Island is truly a culinary delight. One of the well-known restaurants in downtown Put-In-Bay is the Boardwalk Restaurant. An impressive variety of options await hungry diners. Guests can choose from casual fares like Hot Dogs and Cheeseburgers to the more refined like Blackened Mahi Mahi and Lobster Mac and Cheese.
Waterfront Dining Options!
The Boardwalk is known for its famous Lobster Bisque, of which over a million have been served. On the top deck, guests can indulge in tasty tacos and nachos at Rita’s Cantina. Add a delicious Margarita and let the Latin festival begin! For those just seeking a quick bite, there are casual and fast options available on the main deck. Everywhere at The Boardwalk lends dining a beautiful view of Put-In-Bay docks and marinas.
The Keys Restaurant is the sister property to the Boardwalk. It’s located on the other side of the Put-in-Bay docks. This Key West-inspired menu is packed with fresh fish such as Grouper, Mahi Mahi, and Pink Shrimp. The specialty drink menu and craft beers are always a hit. As with the Boardwalk, the Keys does not disappoint with views of the Perry Peace Memorial & the waterfront.
So Many Choices!
The Many Great Put-In-Bay Restaurants rivals that of about any tourist destination. Also, they boast great specials daily. Topsy Turvey is known for its excellent Reuben and Cuban Sandwiches. Hooligans Irish Pub on Catawba Ave is the place for classics like Fish and Chips and a pint. Mossbacks Grille on the corner of Bayview and Catawba Avefeaturessome of the best appetizers, burgers, and entrees on Put-in-Bay. No excuse to leave South Bass Island hungry!
The Put-In-Bay Brewery and Distillery pairs house-made brew with the freshest pizza to go. A few steps away, indulge in a sweet crepe at the Forge Creperie. Their legendary brunch packs them in! Outside patio dining is a great place to people watch. On up to the Reel Bar, where you can choose from inside or outside seating at this locals’ choice eatery.
Are you Hungry Yet? The Chicken Patio next to the Round House Bar grills wine-basted chicken. The secret sauce is a big hit, and you can get just the chicken or a whole meal at Roundhouse Bar. Nearby, Pasquale’s Café has one of the best breakfast menus on the island. Lake Erie Perch is a favorite at The Boathouse Bar and Grille with optional outdoor seating. Enjoy great views of De Rivera Park with some excellent island food.
Late Night Eats And PIZZA PIZZA !!!
Few foods satisfy so many as a great Pizza. Put-in-Bay offers some of the best, and you can even have it delivered poolside or right to your Put-in-Bay Hotel Room. The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company has been delivering piping hot made from scratch pizza for years. Hundreds of thousands have enjoyed their secret sauce made from hand-crushed tomatoes and spices.
Other late-night restaurants for food include the Big Man’s Burrito Stand and new for the 2021 Lesters Taco Shop on the main strip. Enjoy authentic Latin style tacos including Al Pastor, Carne Asada, Beef, Chicken, and Shrimp, With the kids; ice cream is like our pizza fetish!
Put-in-Bay offers several locations to enjoy ice cream creations, including the Candy Bar and the Dairy Isle Each features sweet treats that will satisfy the kids and kids at heart! Grab a dessert piled high with toppings or a hand-dipped cone! We don’t know how many flavors they have but were sure there is one to satisfy your sweet tooth! You can also check out a variety of other dining choices that are not mentioned here on the main restaurant page of our official Put-in-Bay Visitors & Convention Bureau’s website.
Dining In Put In Bay: What You Need to Know
Many restaurants at Put-in-Bay wear two hats. That is to say that during the day and early evening, they are food-focused and by night become high-energy nightspots. There is always a food option available often until well after the local pubs close at 2:00 AM. You can get to any restaurant on the island in a Put-in-Bay Taxi from Coops Cab for just $3.00.
No need to drive! All restaurants accept major credit cards as well as travelers’ checks. ATMs are located in front t of the Edgewater Hotel on the main strip and the lobby of the Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center. From nationally known musical acts to comedians, it’s a sure bet sure you’ll find excitement and variety your group will remember for a lifetime.
BY now, you’re probably getting the idea that there are far too many options to enjoy in just one day! We Know! So, plan a Put-in-Bay Vacation and stay with us for a few days! We promise! We can help you plan what to pack for a Put-in-Bay Vacation! We will keep you well-fed, entertained, and challenged!