Dairy Isle – You Scream I Scream We All Scream For ICE CREAM!

Picture of Dairy Isle213 Bayview Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Dairy Isle

Visitors disembarking from the Jet Express Terminal will see Dairy Isle located on the left on Bayview Avenue. With its bright yellow umbrellas on the patio and delicious menu inside, Dairy Isle makes a perfect first or last stop on Put-in-Bay.

Dairy Isle Particulars

Dairy Isle is committed to providing flavorful and delicious treats and meals. Dairy Isle is located in front of The Keys Restaurant and right down the street from The Perry International Peace Memorial Monument. Hundreds of tourists visit for fast and affordable meals. Relax and enjoy a homemade waffle-cone topped with a delightful serving of their delicious ice cream. In the mood for something to eat? They offer an extended menu, which includes burgers, sandwiches, smoothies, Starbucks’s coffee, and their famous Crazy Fries!

Enjoy your ice cream or meal in their dazzling dining area, or go outside and grab a table and enjoy the magnificent view and warm summer day. Their menu is family-friendly and impossible to pass up, so stop into The Dairy Isle for delicious ice cream or a tasty meal!

Located right next to DeRivera Park and close to all the best downtown attractions, a trip to Dairy Isle is pretty much a given on your day out on the town. Enjoy the sight of Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial, the banks of Lake Erie, and the locals of Put-in-Bay walking by while you enjoy your tasty treats. You can even see Middle Bass Island from here.

The menu at Dairy Isle includes ice cream confections, savory bites, and smoothies. This family-owned and operated spot is wallet-friendly with plenty of delicious offerings — an excellent place for a quick, refreshing snack.

Dairy Isle Lunch Menu Highlights

  • Bacon & Cheddar Fries
  • Island Salad with goat cheese, pecans, and cranberries
  • Lake Erie Perch Sandwiches
  • Veggie Hummus
  • Chicken Tender Combo
  • Bacon Cheeseburger

After Dinner Sweets

  • Turtle Sundae
  • Banana Split
  • Oreo Sundae
  • Strawberry Shortcake

If you are in the mood for something a bit healthier, order one of their smoothies. Their fruity offerings include the Tropical Trio and Berry Blast. The Mocha Java and Chocolate Peanut Butter  Smoothie are both fulling and healthy. Add one of their boosts for an additional health kick.

Dairy Isle Smoothie Boosters

  • Whey Protein
  • Matcha
  • Flax Seeds
  • Chia Seeds
  • Organic Cocoa Powder
  • Cafe Mocha

No matter what you order, you’ll love it. The atmosphere is so festive and friendly here, an accurate encapsulation of summer at Put-in-Bay!

The Dairy Isle can host groups and parties of all sizes! Just give them a call and let them know you are coming, and they will have your meals hot, fresh, and ready to go when your group arrives. It’s is an excellent area of the island to spend the entire day. DeRivera Park across the street is a lovely spot to enjoy your ice cream. They have beautiful playgrounds perfect for kids of all ages. There are also picnic tables throughout the park. Public restrooms are in the bathhouse as well as lockers and showers.

Kimberly’s Carousel is also right nearby. This vintage ride looks much the same as it did when it was built over 100 years ago. Hand-painted animals merrily go round while joyous music spills into the streets. A true Put-in-Bay icon, Kimberly’s delights riders of all ages!

If you are looking for adult beverages after hitting up the ice cream, the Boathouse Bar & Grill and the Margaritas On The Rock are both close by. These two spots serve up substantial, delicious cocktails along with live music. There’s no better place than downtown Put-in-Bay in the summer!