Frosty Pizza – Over 60 years of Pizza Done Right

Picture of Frosty Pizza252 Delaware Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Frosty Pizza & Bar

The Frosty Pizza Bar has been a Put-in-Bay institution for over 60 years and operated by the Stoiber family. There are a lot of Put in Bay Bars, but Frosty is known for serving up ice cold beers in their signature frosty mugs. Boaters, day-trippers, vacationers, and Island natives all call Frosty Pizza one of their favorites. Frosty is a classic dive bar with a Put-in-Bay twist. With extra delicious food served up alongside live music, pool tables, and the game on TV, it is the perfect spot to celebrate summer on Put-in-Bay. In the evenings, a DJ or Duo entertains the masses! Be sure to check the Put-in-Bay Entertainment Schedule to see who’s playing!

Big Man’s Burrito Stand is located at the rear of the property and serves the best Mexican food on the island. Frosty serves up classic American fare with a serious side of flavor.

Frosty Pizza Bar Menu Highlights

  • Country Benedict
  • Gyro
  • Breadsticks
  • Triple Pepperoni Pizza
  • Buttermilk and Whole Grain Pancakes
  • Buffalo Ranch Pizza

Their legendary breakfast menu is always a hit on the island. Often there is a short wait, but you can sip coffee or one of their brunch cocktails while you wait. A little “Hair of the Dog” is very useful at Frosty. Favorites include their heaping breakfast sandwiches, delicious blueberry pancakes, and the infamous Eggs Benedict.

Some of the best Bloody Mary’s can be found at Frosty Pizza, topped off with a signature Frosty pickle. They make a wide variety of innovative cocktails for all hours of the day.

Frosty’s Bar Specialty Cocktail Offerings

  • -Spicy Peppercorn Bloody Mary
  • -Cafe Cooler
  • -Beer-Mosa (Shock Top Belgian White Ale and orange juice)
  • -Cuban Orange Juice
  • -Tropical Mimosa
  • -Garlic Herb Bloody Mary

Ideally located close to most Put-in-Bay Hotels,  Frosty Pizza is an excellent first or last spot on the island. Swing by for a bite before visiting one of the many Put-in-Bay attractions on the island. 

After a hearty meal at Frosty Pizza Bar, why not enjoy a little shopping? There are many local gift shops, steps away! The Country House, Lovella Fashion Apparel, Put-in-Bay Surf  Shop, and the Carriage House are only a few along the Delaware Avenue strip!