Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

Picture of Put-in-Bay Pizza439 Loraine Ave
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

Put-in-Bay Pizza – The #1 Ranked Pizza Delivery 5 Years In A Row!

Fact! No matter where we are on vacation, everyone from time to time loves a well made Pizza. The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company has been serving up the islands top-ranked pizza for years and delivers hot a fresh to Put-in-Bay Hotels, Home Rentals, or residences. The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company uses a unique three cheese blend of Mozzarella, Muenster & Provolone combined with a rich and sassy tomato sauce all over a crispy on the air-filled bottom crust. The Put-in-Bay Pizza toppings are delivered fresh twice weekly, and only the highest quality ingredients end up on the steaming hot pie.

Specialty Pizzas are their niche and are some of the best we’ve ever tried! Among our favorites are:

  • The BBQ Chicken Pizza-Sweet Baby Rays sweet and tangy BBQ sauce serves as the base for this delicious pie topped with slow-smoked chicken and a three cheese blend.
  • The Pepperoni King Pizza-Covered from edge to edge with crispy cooked pepperoni, this classic pie gets the royal treatment!
  • The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza-Forget the red sauce this flavorful pizza starts with Ranch Dressing as the base then get an ample coating of a three cheese blend. Their tasty fajita chicken is diced into bite-size pieces with diced freshly cooked bacon pieces and baked to a golden brown on top.

Put-in-Bay Pizza is the Star, But The Sandwiches Earn Best Supporting Actor!

With over 15 Grinder Sandwiches cooked open-faced in a 505 Degree oven on a fresh baked sub roll, there undoubtedly one to appeal to your taste buds! These famous sandwiches are 10 inches long and served with chips and a giant dill pickle. Among the favorites are:

  • The Chicken Fajita Grinder- Diced Chicken Fajita Meat cooked with green peppers and onions smothered in a three-cheese blend on freshly baked bread.
  • The Stromboli- Afreashly baked sub roll topped with Pizza Sauce, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers & onion baked with a three cheese blend
  • The Italian- Pepperoni, Salami, and a spicy ham baked with a three cheese blend and topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and Italian dressing.

Put-in-Bay Pizza offers A variety of seasonal salads, breadsticks, and appetizers.

The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Delivers! Delivery to anywhere on the island is just a phone call away! They accept all major credit cards and are open late at night during the season. Check the local Put-in-Bay Gazette News for valuable coupons for pick up at the famous Put-in-Bay Resort located in the downtown business district near the Blue Marlin Grill. If you are looking for a great picnic idea, call ahead and take a few out to the Oak Point State Park for lunch with the family!